Short answer
Often, but not always. Agastache (hummingbird mint, giant hyssop, anise hyssop) is a perennial, and many plants return for several years in the right conditions. But many are short-lived, and in colder or wet-winter areas they sometimes die out and get treated as annuals.
Why it sometimes does not come back
The most common cause is winter wetness, not cold alone. Agastache has a crown that tends to rot in cold, soggy soil. Other factors:
- Heavy clay or poorly drained soil. The same plant may survive a cold winter in sandy soil and fail in clay.
- Rich soil and extra fertilizer. Fast, soft growth tends to be less hardy.
- Late pruning. Cutting back late in the season can stimulate new growth that winter damages.
- Hardiness mismatch. Many Agastache are listed as hardy in roughly zones 5 through 10, and some are hardy to zone 3 or 4. Southwestern species and hybrids are often the least cold-hardy.
Anise hyssop and southwestern Agastache
Not all Agastache behave the same:
- Anise hyssop (Agastache foeniculum) is native to the northern and central United States and southern Canada. It is generally cold-hardy and tends to self-seed, so a patch often persists even when individual plants die.
- Southwestern and Mexican types, such as Agastache rupestris, A. aurantiaca and many hybrids, have orange, pink or rose flowers that hummingbirds like. They need sharp drainage and sun, and often struggle with wet winters or humidity.
If you want a dependable plant in cold climates, start with anise hyssop. If you want the showier hybrids, treat them as a bonus and plant them where drainage is best.
Helping it survive winter
- Plant in full sun in lean, well-drained soil. Add grit in heavy soil, or plant on a slight mound.
- Avoid fertilizer, especially in the first year.
- Don’t cut back hard in fall. Leave stems standing through winter and trim in spring when new growth appears.
- Skip heavy mulch over the crown, which can hold moisture. A light mulch of gravel or leaves in winter is safer in cold regions.
- Plant in spring in cold zones, so roots can establish before the first winter.
- Take cuttings in late summer from favorite plants. Rooted cuttings can be overwintered indoors, the same way gardeners keep tender perennials.
Self-seeding and replacement
Leave some seed heads standing. Finches eat them, and anise hyssop especially tends to seed itself. In some climates, replacing a plant every few years is simply part of growing it. You can also divide plants in spring, though many gardeners find cuttings or seed easier.
For more, see perennial herbs for bees, which compares true hyssop with anise hyssop, and hummingbird plants for other tubular-flowered choices.