Native and Pollinator Perennials

Best Milkweed Varieties for Monarchs: Butterfly Weed, Swamp and Common

Compare swamp, common and butterfly weed milkweed for monarchs: which suits your site, which spreads, which to skip, and how to start them from seed.

On this page
  1. Pick native milkweed for your region
  2. Swamp milkweed (Asclepias incarnata)
  3. Common milkweed (Asclepias syriaca)
  4. Butterfly weed (Asclepias tuberosa)
  5. Other native milkweeds
  6. Tropical milkweed: why many experts say skip it
  7. Growing milkweed
  8. Quick chooser

Pick native milkweed for your region

Monarch caterpillars eat only milkweed (Asclepias), so milkweed is the plant that matters most for them. The best choice is a native species suited to your region, because it will match your climate and the timing of local monarchs. There are many native milkweeds in North America, and the best species for you depends on where you live. Check your state or regional native plant resources.

The three below are widely grown across the central and eastern United States.

Swamp milkweed (Asclepias incarnata)

  • Flowers: pink to rose clusters in summer.
  • Site: moist to average soil, in sun. Despite the name, it adapts to ordinary garden soil.
  • Habit: upright clump, usually well behaved, which makes it a good option for small and ornamental yards.
  • For monarchs: often reported as a favorite for egg-laying, and the leaves feed caterpillars.

It also does well in rain gardens, as covered in native perennials for a rain garden, and in clay.

Common milkweed (Asclepias syriaca)

  • Flowers: large, fragrant, dusty-pink globes in early to midsummer.
  • Site: full sun, a wide range of soils.
  • Habit: spreads by underground runners and can form big patches. It is an excellent choice for meadows and larger spaces, but can be too assertive for a small border.
  • For monarchs: large, soft leaves are a favored food, and the plant is often described as a top host.

Give it room, or plant it where spreading is fine.

Butterfly weed (Asclepias tuberosa)

  • Flowers: bright orange (sometimes yellow-orange) flat clusters in early to midsummer.
  • Site: full sun and dry, well-drained soil. It resents wet feet and being moved, since it grows a long taproot.
  • Habit: a clumping plant that rarely spreads.
  • For monarchs: an important nectar plant and a host plant, though some studies and observers say monarchs lay fewer eggs on it than on swamp or common milkweed.

It is slow to emerge in spring, so mark where it is planted.

Other native milkweeds

Depending on your region, also consider whorled milkweed (Asclepias verticillata), a short, fine-leaved plant for dry sites, and showy milkweed (Asclepias speciosa) or narrowleaf milkweed (Asclepias fascicularis) in the western states. Local nurseries and native plant societies can confirm what is native near you.

Tropical milkweed: why many experts say skip it

Tropical milkweed (Asclepias curassavica) is a non-native species with red and orange flowers that is widely sold. In mild climates it stays green through the winter, which may disrupt monarch migration and allow a parasite (Ophryocystis elektroscirrha, “OE”) to build up. Guidance from groups such as university extension programs is generally to plant native milkweed instead, or, if you already have tropical milkweed in a warm area, to cut it back hard in fall.

Growing milkweed

  • Seed needs cold. Most native milkweed seed germinates better after a period of cold, moist conditions. Sowing in fall, or chilling seed in the refrigerator for several weeks before spring sowing, are common approaches. See how to grow native perennial wildflowers from seed.
  • Be patient. Milkweed often takes a couple of years to bloom from seed.
  • Expect chewed leaves. That is the point. Aphids, which are common on milkweed, can often be sprayed off with water.
  • Handle with care. Milkweed sap is toxic if eaten and can irritate skin and eyes. Wash your hands after handling, and keep it away from livestock and pets that might chew it.

Quick chooser

Species Best for Spread Moisture
Swamp milkweed Small gardens, rain gardens, clay Low Moist to average
Common milkweed Meadows and large areas High Average to dry
Butterfly weed Dry, sunny, well-drained sites Low Dry

For a bigger plan that also feeds adult butterflies and bees, see our native perennials guide.

The complete guide to native and pollinator perennials

Native Perennial Wildflowers for Pollinators
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →