Why clay is tricky for drought-tolerant plants
Clay soil holds water and nutrients well, but it drains slowly. That creates two problems for plants that are drought tolerant:
- In wet seasons the soil can stay soggy, which is hard on plants that prefer a dry crown, especially in winter.
- In dry weather clay can bake hard and crack, making it hard for water to soak in, and it can be difficult for young roots to push through.
So the best plants for dry, sunny clay are those that tolerate both wet feet in the off-season and dry spells in summer. Many prairie and meadow natives fit this description because their native soils are heavy.
Perennials that cope with clay and dry spells
Tolerance varies with the cultivar and the severity of your clay, so treat these as good candidates rather than guarantees.
- Purple coneflower (Echinacea purpurea): widely described as tolerant of clay and drought once established. Its roots can help open up heavy soil.
- Black-eyed Susan (Rudbeckia): sturdy, sun-loving and forgiving of neglect, and commonly grown in clay.
- Baptisia (false indigo): a deep-rooted native with blue, yellow or purple flower spikes. It is slow to establish but long-lived, and it dislikes being moved.
- Daylily (Hemerocallis): tough and adaptable in clay, with fleshy roots that cope with dry periods.
- Upright sedum (Hylotelephium): typically fine in average to heavy soil if the site does not stay waterlogged.
- Bee balm (Monarda fistulosa) and gayfeather (Liatris): often grown in clay, though they like a bit more moisture than the toughest dry-garden plants.
- Switchgrass and little bluestem: native grasses that cope with clay in many regions; see whether switch grass is invasive for how switchgrass spreads.
- Amsonia (blue star): a native perennial often described as adaptable to clay and dry spells.
- Shasta daisy: reported to do well in clay, though it often lives longer in better-drained soil.
Plants to be cautious with
Some popular dry-garden plants prefer sharper drainage, and heavy clay can shorten their lives. These include lavender, ice plant, blanket flower, Russian sage in wet winters and many silver-leaved plants; see silver-leaved perennials for full sun. If you want to grow them, plant them on a raised mound, a slope or in a raised bed, or add grit around the root zone.
Hostas appear on some “clay soil” lists, but they are shade plants that need regular moisture, so they are not a drought-tolerant choice for a sunny site.
Planting in clay
- Don’t fill the hole with sand or loose compost. A pocket of loose soil in clay can act like a bowl and hold water around the roots.
- Dig a wide, shallow hole instead of a deep one, and break up compacted sides so roots can spread out.
- Plant slightly high. Setting the crown at or just above the surrounding soil level, or planting on a low mound, helps protect it from winter wet.
- Mix a little compost with the native soil rather than replacing the soil.
- Plant when the soil is workable but not sticky. Working wet clay can compact it.
- Mulch to slow evaporation and reduce cracking, keeping it off the crowns.
Watering clay
Clay holds moisture longer, so it needs less frequent watering than sandy soil, but water must be applied slowly so it soaks in rather than running off. Check the soil a few inches down before watering. For a general framework, see how often to water drought-tolerant perennials in their first year.
Improving clay over time
You can improve clay gradually by top-dressing with compost each year, adding mulch and avoiding walking on wet soil. Deep-rooted plants also help over time. Rapid, one-time fixes such as adding sand rarely work. If water sits on the site for long periods, it is usually better to change the grade or build a raised bed.
For more ideas that suit sunny, dry sites, see perennials for sunny borders and dry gardens, and for sloping clay, see perennials for hot, dry slopes and erosion control.