Annual or Perennial

Hardy Mums and Heather: Will Fall Plants Come Back?

Hardy mums are perennial but often fail when planted in fall, while heather (Calluna vulgaris) is an evergreen perennial. Learn how to help both return.

On this page
  1. Quick answers
  2. Hardy mums: perennial, but fall-bought plants are a gamble
  3. How to help mums come back
  4. Heather (Calluna vulgaris)

Quick answers

Plant Type Will it come back?
Hardy (garden) mum Perennial Often, if planted early and given good conditions
Florist or fall-display mum Perennial in theory Frequently not, especially when bought in bloom in fall
Heather (Calluna vulgaris) Evergreen perennial shrub Yes, in suitable climates and acidic, well-drained soil

Hardy mums: perennial, but fall-bought plants are a gamble

Garden mums (chrysanthemums) are perennials. Many are rated for roughly zones 5 to 9, with some sources listing zones 4 to 9 depending on the variety. The trouble is that mums sold in fall are often bred for a spectacular bloom display, not winter survival. They are frequently in full flower when you buy them, and a plant putting its energy into blooms has little left for roots. Planted in autumn, these mums often have too little time to root before the ground freezes, and they commonly do not return.

How long do mums live? Garden mums grown in the right conditions may last a few years, and gardeners often see them decline after about three or four, at which point dividing them can renew them. Hardiness depends on variety and local conditions, so check the tag.

How to help mums come back

  • Plant early. Spring planting gives the roots a full season. If you plant in fall, get plants in the ground as early as possible, ideally well before hard freezes.
  • Plant in the ground, not in a shallow pot. Roots in containers are exposed to freezing air, so they are usually less protected than plants in soil.
  • Choose sun. See do mums like sun or shade for light requirements.
  • Water consistently through late summer and fall, especially in dry spells.
  • Mulch after the soil cools to help insulate the roots.
  • Cutting back: Many gardeners leave the old stems through winter for added protection, then cut them back in spring as new growth appears. Others cut down after frost. Both methods are used.
  • Pinching: In spring and early summer, pinch growing tips for bushier plants, and stop around midsummer so flower buds can form.

If you are keeping mums over winter in a pot, a sheltered unheated location such as a garage may help, though results vary and there is no guarantee.

Heather (Calluna vulgaris)

Calluna vulgaris, often called Scottish heather or ling, is an evergreen perennial shrub, not an annual. It is commonly sold in fall as a colorful container plant, but it is a long-lived plant in suitable conditions. It generally prefers full sun, acidic, well-drained soil and a cool climate. Heather is usually hardy in colder zones, but it may struggle in hot, humid summers or heavy, alkaline soil.

Trimming lightly after flowering, without cutting into old bare wood (the same rule as pruning lavender), helps keep plants compact.

Heather questions

  • Is Calluna vulgaris evergreen? Yes, the foliage stays on the plant through winter, though color can shift to bronze or purple in cold weather.
  • Do heathers spread quickly? Calluna is generally a slow to moderate grower that forms low mounds or mats, so it is not typically described as fast spreading.
  • Is heather safe for cats? Safety information varies by source, so check a reliable pet-toxicity resource or ask a veterinarian before planting it where pets graze.
  • What about Mexican heather? Mexican heather (Cuphea hyssopifolia) is a different plant that is tender and perennial only in warm climates; it is not related to true heather.

For other long-lived plants, see our guide to what separates annuals and perennials.

The complete guide to annual or perennial

Annual vs Perennial Flowers: How to Tell Which Plants Come Back
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →