The short answer
It depends on which plant you have. True geraniums, also called hardy geraniums or cranesbills, are perennials that die back in autumn and return in spring. The bold, colorful “geraniums” sold for pots, window boxes and bedding are usually Pelargoniums, which are tender perennials. They survive only in mild climates unless you protect them from frost.
Geranium vs Pelargonium
The two groups were once classified together, which is why the common name stuck. Today they are separate genera, and the difference matters for winter survival.
| Hardy geranium (cranesbill) | Pelargonium | |
|---|---|---|
| Hardiness | Hardy in many cold climates | Frost-tender |
| Returns each year? | Yes, where hardy | Only in mild climates, or if overwintered |
| Typical use | Borders, ground cover | Containers, bedding, window boxes |
| Flowers | Open, often five-petaled, simple | Rounded clusters, fuller blooms |
| Common types | ‘Rozanne’ and many others | Zonal, ivy, regal, scented-leaf |
How to tell them apart
- Check the botanical name on the tag. Geranium means hardy; Pelargonium means tender.
- Leaves: Hardy types often have softer, deeply divided leaves; many Pelargoniums have thicker, rounder leaves, sometimes with a darker zone or marking.
- Flowers: Cranesbill flowers are generally simple and open, while Pelargonium flowers are usually held in tight clusters, and many have two petals that differ from the other three.
- Growth habit: Hardy geraniums tend to mound or spread, while Pelargoniums are often upright or trailing.
Hardy geraniums: care and return
Hardy geraniums are low-maintenance perennials. Hardiness depends on the species and variety, and many are reliable in cold zones. They die back or lose leaves in winter and regrow in spring. Cut back tired foliage after flowering or in late winter to encourage fresh growth, and divide clumps every few years if they get congested. Well-drained soil suits most types.
Pelargoniums: overwintering
In regions with frost, Pelargoniums are usually treated as annuals or overwintered. Roughly zones 9 to 11 are commonly given as the range where they may live outdoors year-round.
- Bring pots indoors before the first frost and keep them in a bright, cool window, watering sparingly.
- Take cuttings in late summer: 3- to 4-inch stems, let the cut end dry for a day, then root them in gritty, barely moist mix.
- Dormant storage: Some gardeners lift plants, shake off the soil and store them in a cool, dark, frost-free place such as an unheated garage, checking occasionally for mold and watering lightly. Results vary.
- Replant after frost is past, once the weather warms.
This is the same approach used for other tender perennials.
Which should you choose?
Choose a hardy geranium for ground cover, borders and a plant that returns with little fuss. Choose a Pelargonium for bold color in pots, baskets and window boxes, accepting that you may replant or overwinter it each year. Many gardens use both.