What deadheading does (and doesn’t)
Deadheading is removing spent flowers. Depending on the plant, it can:
- Keep the plant looking tidy.
- Stop it from setting seed, which can limit self-seeding.
- Encourage a second round of flowers on some plants.
It does not help every plant. Plants that bloom once and do not rebloom gain little beyond appearance, and some are better left with their seed heads for wildlife or winter interest. For the wider routine, see our guide to how to care for perennials.
Deadheading astilbe
Astilbe is generally not deadheaded for the sake of more blooms. It normally flowers once in its season, and removing the faded plumes does not typically trigger a second flush. Gardeners cut them for two reasons:
- Appearance. Flower plumes fade to brown. Cutting the stalks near the base removes them.
- Winter interest. Many people leave the dried plumes standing through winter and cut them back in late winter or early spring.
Either choice is fine. If you do cut, use clean pruners and cut the flower stalk where it meets the foliage rather than shearing the leaves.
Light requirements for astilbe
Astilbe usually does best in part shade, with morning sun and shade in the hottest part of the afternoon. It can tolerate more sun if the soil stays consistently moist, but the foliage tends to scorch in hot, dry conditions. Deep shade often means fewer flowers.
How to pronounce astilbe
It is commonly pronounced “uh-STIL-bee”.
The downsides of astilbe
Honest drawbacks gardeners mention include:
- It needs steady moisture and can brown at the edges in dry spells.
- It can struggle in heat, full sun or dry shade.
- It tends to clump slowly, and older clumps may need dividing.
- It blooms for a limited period compared with some perennials.
- Some deer and rabbits will browse it, depending on the area.
Deadheading garden phlox
Tall garden phlox (Phlox paniculata) is the plant most often deadheaded among the pair. Once the first flower clusters fade, cutting them off can lead to later flowers from side shoots, and it limits seed production. Phlox seedlings can differ from the parent plant. Many gardeners find they come up in a plain magenta, crowding out named varieties.
How to do it:
- Wait until most of the florets in a cluster have faded.
- Follow the stem down to the first set of healthy leaves or a pair of small side buds.
- Cut just above them with clean, sharp pruners.
- Avoid snipping off the small new side shoots, since these produce the next flowers.
Some gardeners skip the task and let phlox self-seed. That is a legitimate choice if you are happy with the seedlings.
Powdery mildew
Phlox is prone to powdery mildew. Airflow helps, so give plants space, thin crowded stems, and consider dividing congested clumps. Mildew-resistant varieties are widely sold. Water at the base of the plant if you can.
Should you cut back garden phlox in the fall?
It is a reasonable idea to cut it back after the foliage has died down or after frost, especially if the leaves had mildew, since removing infected material reduces the problems carried over. Some gardeners instead leave the stems until spring. If seedlings are a concern, cut off seed heads before they ripen.
Fertilizer for phlox
Phlox does not generally need heavy feeding. A top-dressing of compost in spring and a balanced or flower-focused fertilizer used according to the label are typical. Too much nitrogen can encourage soft foliage and fewer flowers.
Creeping phlox
Creeping phlox (Phlox subulata) is handled differently. It is usually sheared lightly after its spring bloom to tidy it and encourage dense growth, rather than snipped flower by flower. Rebloom, if any, is modest.
Common deadheading mistakes
- Cutting too much. Taking off healthy side buds or large amounts of foliage slows rebloom.
- Using dull or dirty tools. These crush stems and can spread disease. Clean blades between plants, especially if you saw mildew.
- Deadheading plants that don’t rebloom and then removing seed heads other creatures use.
- Cutting at the wrong spot. Cut just above a leaf set or side bud rather than leaving a long bare stub.
- Waiting too long. Once seed has formed, much of the benefit is gone.
- Expecting the same result from every plant. Check what your specific plant does.
When to skip it
Skipping deadheading makes sense when:
- You want the plant to self-seed.
- Birds feed on the seed heads, as with coneflowers and black-eyed Susans.
- The plant does not rebloom, as is usually true for astilbe.
- You like the dried look in winter.
- The task is not worth the time, and your garden is meant to be low maintenance.
Sometimes leaving the plants alone is the right care.